Florida Judge Quotes Christmas Movie In Ruling Obama Eligible

Florida Democrat Michael Voeltz had filed a lawsuit against Barack Obama’s eligibility to serve as President of the United States and claimed that he was a threat to the safety and security of the United States.  Larry Klayman, founder of Freedom WatchUSA served as Voeltz’s attorney on the case.

On Dec. 13, Florida Circuit Court of Leon County Judge Kevin Carroll gave the plaintiffs until Dec. 23 to respond to Obama’s attorneys’ motion to dismiss the case.  However, Judge Carroll went against his own order and dismissed the case on the 21st.  In his dismissal, Carroll wrote:

“This court notes that President Obama lives in the White House. He flies on Air Force One. He has appeared before Congress, delivered State of the Union addresses and meets with congressional leaders on a regular basis. He has appointed countless ambassadors to represent the interests of the United States throughout the world.”

“As this matter has come before the court at this time of the year it seems only appropriate to paraphrase the ruling rendered by the fictional Judge Henry X. Harper from New York in open court in the classic holiday film ‘Miracle on 34th St.’ ‘Since the United States Government declares this man to be president, this court will not dispute it. Case dismissed.’”

Carroll’s dismissal was immediately challenged by Klayman claiming that the judge prematurely dismissed the case without a proper hearing as described by state law.  Klayman explained:

“This act also flies in the face of this court’s own order of Dec. 13, 2012, which was law of the case.”

“This court had a statutory duty under the Florida Election laws, the Florida and U.S. Constitutions, and 3 U.S.C. Section 5, to adjudicate defendant Obama’s eligibility and his alleged fraudulent acts expeditiously, timely, and before the electors met on Dec. 17, 2012, and before the Electoral College votes on Jan. 6, 2013.  Thus, this court also violated these law is dismissing the complaint summarily.”

“This court seems to want to sidestep having to reach these serious and important matters before it.”

Klayman also noted that Judge Carroll made an inappropriate remark concerning a friend of his who had been appointed to a federal post by Obama and indicated that it may demonstrate bias on the part of the judge.

Carroll also ignored all of the evidence that Klayman had that strongly questions the legitimacy of Obama’s birth certificate and other documentation.  In plain words, Carroll succumbed to the pressures put upon him by the White House attorneys to ignore the US Constitution, federal and state law and dismiss the case.  This administration’s record is looking more and more like those of the German Gestapo or Stalin’s KGB, only without the obvious trail of dead bodies.



270 thoughts on “Florida Judge Quotes Christmas Movie In Ruling Obama Eligible

  1. This administration’s record is looking more and more like those of the German Gestapo or Stalin’s KGB, only without the obvious trail of dead bodies...yet!

  2. This is proof that you can male it in the law profession and know absolutly nothing about the law.

  3. So we know who's back pocket this judge resides in...Shameful ...Unethical .. This is our legal system at it's corrupt best!!

  4. Did this idiot judge ever consider the mail sent to the wrong addressy...? No don't live in the real world; borrow from the world of fantasy and fiction. No don't follow and respect the laws of this nation! If this judge is not responsible enough to carry out the laws of this nation and his state he is not doing his job and he should be stripped of his judgeship. Where is his responsibility to the Constitution, the Bill of Rights and the Amendments?

  5. PArevolutionary says:

    He was probably paid off or threatened

  6. I feel like I'm the Twilight Zone. Has everyone gone mad????? Some judges are making decisions based on Shariah law - and now one is using a Hollywood movie as precedent! It feels like Mao's China - put all of the intellects in the field to farm and take all of the uneducated morons and put them in positions of power. The whole country has turned upside down!! Reminds me of the idiot Congressman from GA who thinks Guam could tip over!!! It would seem that the Libtards have been teaching our children for far too long.

  7. "Obvious trail of dead body's"??? ARE YOU F%^&*NG BLIND????????????

  8. This judge, along wth his decision making policies is a JOKE!

  9. How did this guy retain his bench?

  10. This judge is a joke and didn't even have one thing to say about the evidence, I thought that is what judges do? America is in big trouble when the courts act in this fashion!!!

  11. Don C. Hayward says:

    Can there ever be a more telling example of what we have become as a nation than an examination of this fools remarks as it relates to Constitutional eligibility.

  12. just another criminal communist judge, whose only constitutional future is, the gallows. that conga line to the gallows, grows by the day.

  13. When the court doesn't abide by the law, then there is no law. There is no reason to abide by anything that comes out of our former court system.

  14. Speaking of movies, a must read. "Hollywood Reds on the Run" by Myron C Fagan. They never realy left. They just gave up 10 for under the buss. Just ask Ed A. As for the judge, if you can by a vote, you can buy a judge. That goes for the top dog of judges too. Justice my opinion.

  15. What kind of a dipstick judge is this guy?

    Next he will be telling us that the Moon is made of green cheese, because it's in a fairy tale.
    Or the Earth is flat because some people leave on a boat and don't come back.

    Are judges elected in Florida? If so remember this at the next election. If they are appointed, start impeachment proceedings now.

    Wasn't it in Florida where a judge was impeached because he was taking bribes from the Mob, then the people elected him to the Congress? Elsee Hastings!

  16. Even the Judges think Hollywood is real life and he probably uses Hollywood to make many or most of his or her decisions in real life. These Judges are unable to distinguish between real life and like Hollywood pretend life so what we see in our courts today are nothing but pretend decisions.

  17. "This administration’s record is looking more and more like those of the
    German Gestapo or Stalin’s KGB, only without the obvious trail of dead

    Really? I'm sure folks across the Mideast might disagree with that assessment.

  18. This poser of a "judge" needs to be impeached & it has happened before to a judge in Fla, an idiot by the name of Alcee Hastings, who now is a sitting democrap congressman in the same state!!!! Way to go, commie/lib bastards!!!!!!!!!!!!

  19. How many people are in on the conspiracy? What are the goals? Everything is a lie. No serious legal scholars anywhere. The people represented by those that took an oath to protect this nation from domestic enemies and uphold the rule of law, should be given the same respect they give us, Absolutely NONE. All the time, everywhere you see a politician a professor a cop or a lawyer tell them they are ignorant or criminal neither of which is acceptable. Change the Law or obey it. Our P.O.T.U.S. is an illegal alien with a stolen SS#. God Bless Sheriff Joe and Susan Daniels.

  20. Impeach this judge! If he is listening to anyone instead of following the law, he needs to be kicked out of his job. What a dismal display of the perverted justice system. Just ignore the constitutional laws and do whatever you wish. I have seen a copy of Obama's Occidental records, and he was listed as a Kenyan. Now why have we not heard the MSM talking about this illegal in the whitehouse? This judge should be removed as soon as possible.