Florida Judge Quotes Christmas Movie In Ruling Obama Eligible

Florida Democrat Michael Voeltz had filed a lawsuit against Barack Obama’s eligibility to serve as President of the United States and claimed that he was a threat to the safety and security of the United States.  Larry Klayman, founder of Freedom WatchUSA served as Voeltz’s attorney on the case.

On Dec. 13, Florida Circuit Court of Leon County Judge Kevin Carroll gave the plaintiffs until Dec. 23 to respond to Obama’s attorneys’ motion to dismiss the case.  However, Judge Carroll went against his own order and dismissed the case on the 21st.  In his dismissal, Carroll wrote:

“This court notes that President Obama lives in the White House. He flies on Air Force One. He has appeared before Congress, delivered State of the Union addresses and meets with congressional leaders on a regular basis. He has appointed countless ambassadors to represent the interests of the United States throughout the world.”

“As this matter has come before the court at this time of the year it seems only appropriate to paraphrase the ruling rendered by the fictional Judge Henry X. Harper from New York in open court in the classic holiday film ‘Miracle on 34th St.’ ‘Since the United States Government declares this man to be president, this court will not dispute it. Case dismissed.’”

Carroll’s dismissal was immediately challenged by Klayman claiming that the judge prematurely dismissed the case without a proper hearing as described by state law.  Klayman explained:

“This act also flies in the face of this court’s own order of Dec. 13, 2012, which was law of the case.”

“This court had a statutory duty under the Florida Election laws, the Florida and U.S. Constitutions, and 3 U.S.C. Section 5, to adjudicate defendant Obama’s eligibility and his alleged fraudulent acts expeditiously, timely, and before the electors met on Dec. 17, 2012, and before the Electoral College votes on Jan. 6, 2013.  Thus, this court also violated these law is dismissing the complaint summarily.”

“This court seems to want to sidestep having to reach these serious and important matters before it.”

Klayman also noted that Judge Carroll made an inappropriate remark concerning a friend of his who had been appointed to a federal post by Obama and indicated that it may demonstrate bias on the part of the judge.

Carroll also ignored all of the evidence that Klayman had that strongly questions the legitimacy of Obama’s birth certificate and other documentation.  In plain words, Carroll succumbed to the pressures put upon him by the White House attorneys to ignore the US Constitution, federal and state law and dismiss the case.  This administration’s record is looking more and more like those of the German Gestapo or Stalin’s KGB, only without the obvious trail of dead bodies.



Posted in 2012 Election, Constitution, Law, Liberalism, Politics Tagged with: , , , , , ,
  • fedfreakinup

    judge should be disbarred

  • 2War Abn Vet

    Note that “eligibility”, which was the cause of the suit, was not mentioned in the decision.

  • Gregg Weber

    The fictional judge put a USPS employee’s decision above the written Constitution. This living “judge” said that wrong is OK if it has happened and he will not correct any error (if there was an error) or even judge the matter. That ain’t no judge.

  • jim

    I’m waiting for the courts to use a paraphrase from the movie Ice Age for the ruling in their court ! It would be the same thing.

    • Patriot

      Not so loud or they’ll hear you! :)

  • jim

    As Sid the Sloth said ” stalking the prey ! “

  • Lauralee Hensley

    That judge is a panty waste. No gonads under that robe in my opinion. That judge must have gotten them whacked off like all the other puppet mastered scarecrows in Washington. They’ll all be sure to take the mark of the beast when that day happens when they can’t even stand up to the little illegal nonsense that’s been going on currently, because it will even be more intense in the near future. Just the handwriting on the wall, yet they won’t turn to any true Christian believers to help them interpret the understanding thereof. At least the Kings of Old turned to God fearing believers to help them interpret or plan for the future. They didn’t always follow through, but they at least listened. We have government officials most of whom are either too afraid to hear and respond to the truth, have killed off any brain cells via drugs or booze they must have once had, or are simply deceived. I bet our government officials must really be making most rulers of other countries in this world happy as they are playing right into theirs and the wicked UN’s hands. For those other countries that once depended upon our nation to be a stronghold in a time of trouble, well I imagine they are sorely saddened and possibly angry at our gonadless nation. I’m sure the patriots that are already buried in our soil, wish they could arise and take back this nation and restore it to what they once fought for. We have let their memories and their sacrifices for us down in my opinion.

  • ETA3

    The judge needs to retire or be voted out, better than that removed from the bench!! Sounds like TREASON to me!!!

  • AmVet

    Obama is just a tool and most liberals are just
    sheep that have been sucked into the fold. Here is a partial response from a
    fellow blogger with a very enlightening video that needs to be seen by all
    “Americans”. This video gives you many of the answers of why the United States
    is in such great turmoil. Through Obama and his band of co-conspirators and
    puppet masters he has destroyed our economy, widen the gap between those that
    have and those that have not and set civil rights and racism back to the 1950’s.
    You have to watch what he does, not what he says he will do because they are not
    the same. He only says what you want to hear him say; but, if it isn’t in his
    plans it will never be done. Every created or unfortunate gun issue gives him
    and his cronies more persuasive arguments to take the only defense against their
    end goal, Our Second Amendment. The Second Amendment (Amendment II) to the
    United States Constitution is the part of the United States Bill of Rights that
    protects the right of the people to keep and bear arms. This was put in the Bill
    of Rights to not only protect us individually but to protect us from the likes
    of Hitler, Marx, Chavis and any other that would try to take control of Our
    personal rights and liberties as a Nation.

    “This Politically Correct
    tolerance movement is the work of Antonio Gramsci and Frankfurt School whose
    agenda was to take down a Judeo/Christian culture from within. The only religion
    the left has a problem with is biblical Christianity now why is that? This is
    the most comprehensive, best movie I have seen pulling all this together. Watch
    it. Share it. It should be mandatory viewing for anyone who loves this

    https://vimeo.com/52009124 if that is not
    working try this: https://vimeo.com/16647512

  • antilevy

    “It’s over Johnny”

  • http://www.facebook.com/dwgray David W Gray

    You who practice deceit, your tongue plots destruction; it is like a sharpened razor. You love evil rather than good, falsehood
    rather than speaking the truth. You love every harmful word, you
    deceitful tongue! Surely God will bring you down to everlasting ruin: He
    will snatch you up and pluck you from your tent; he will uproot you
    from the land of the living. http://bible.us/Ps52.2.NIV

  • The Carpathian

    “Except for the trailof dead bodies”

    Don’t worry the dead bodies will come when the Great and All Powerful Obama signe his declaration of martial law throughout the US … with the “shoot to kill” order damanding that his DHS Gestapo summarily execute anyone found opposing Obama — or trying to escape from a re-education camp.

  • Sandra Lee Smith

    There is a HUGE difference between a fictional opinion concerning the identify of a fictional character and the REAL eligibility of a LIVE USURPER in a high public office, and to equate the 2 as if that former judgment was REAL is a new low in the absurdity and inanity of the mannequins sitting on the benches allegedly administering ” justice” in this nation!

  • tncdel

    So will that be appealed?

  • Puddles

    Lameness rules- this judge has forgotten any law he ever knew. Sad- God help us all

  • dondehoff

    I am not a lawyer but surely this will be appealed. I am sure there are reams of case law on the books wherein persons “got away” with crimes for ages, before they were convicted. Then, it would appear this judge has been unduly influenced somehow, or more likely he was engaged in “aiding and abetting”. When does he come up for voter “approval”? We surely do need a law wherein those guilty of treason, face a public firing squad—I suspect we will even be able to get “group rates”.

  • speedy

    We are becoming Hitler’s Germany! We have no honest judges left in this country! We will soon run out of the rich people’s money to fund our socialism! We are already worse off than Greece! We are the most bankrupt country in the history of the world. But as long as our populace wants freebies and don’t want to work, nothing will change….until the sh.t hits the fan!!! And, by G0d it will!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Paul-Broussard/100000569719030 Paul Broussard

    Jesus Mary and Joseph!
    So the Presidency relies on a &*$#@& Christmas Movie!!!

  • Ron

    Corruption wherever Obama’s name is brought up. He has corrupted the whole judicial system.

  • Brabado

    It is very hard to remember during this Christmas Season, how a once a Great Nation, whatches in Horror, how a mediocreand possibly a Socialist Judge, joins a worthless Governement, in accepting the Great Lie and Fraud perpetrated by Barack Hussein Obama who still, has no produce any concrete valid, and legal confirmation, that he is elegible to be President of the United States, while funny judges, dismiss all the evidence presented before them, challeging his lies and deceptions… Is that how Justice work???

    Yes, we were, ONCE, an Intelligent Nation, full of thinkers, brilliant individulas who rather work than collect Fud Stamps, while respected throughout the whole World!

    Not any more! Now the Country is over-saturated with unreliable and un-trustworthy Demokrats, Socialists, Liberals, Atheist, Progressives, and their free loader minions…

    Pitiful how low the Obama Regime has pushed this Nation into the gutter… Yet, he vacations, non-chalantly, in Hawaii, while the Socialist United Statesof America, goes to hell…


  • paula

    And we are surprised?

Political Outcast Newsletter

Political Outcast email marketing powered by InboxFirst